Newfie Scott
Active Member
Posts: 139
Posted: Sat Oct 08, 2005 12:49 pm
The so-called "PROVINCIAL" class was never set in stone. It was simply one way considered to alleviate the forthcoming problem of the lack of a command and control ship for our task groups. The idea of extending the Halifax class frigates to make them into destroyers was dismissed because it would be extremely expensive to do such a modification and it would ultimately make the ship too unstable (with the required equipment added for SM2, APAR, etc.) to be of any use to the military.
From a purely engineering and economic standpoint, be happy that the PROVINCIAL class was as quickly dismissed as it was as quickly dreamt up.
What is being considered as the only really viable options now are (1) new build project or (2) acquisition of foreign built vessels to fill the role.
And don't believe everything you see on CASR - while they have some concrete information, their "what-ifs" are about as theoretical as religion when it comes to the viability of such platforms. Everytime I read their "ideas" for the Canadian Forces, you can easily tell that they're not approaching the concepts from an engineering standpoint, more of a "we have these things right now, so how can we combine them into a better platform".
As for Hazegray.org, unless it's the United States Navy section, their "future ship classes" information sheets aren't overly impressive to say the least.