Murray_Smith wrote:
Dragon-Dancer wrote:
That seems like a strange thing to say, without a federal (central) government to speak for the country America wouldn't exactly be a country so Fed Govt MUST be America. States power is one thing but without a fed you don't have a single voice.
I thoroughly disagree. A central government does not need to actually speak for the people in order to "be" that country. Rather, the federal government is more like an engine that keeps America running. I am of the opinion that it is usually the population that makes the country, and the United States is not an exception.
Since the fed is voted in by the people to represent them like it or not they do speak for the country. They are the 'face' presented to the outside world and as you say the 'engine' that keeps the country running. A central government is what keeps the country together as a single entity. America as we know it wouldn't exist without it. Instead we would have the country of Texas and the country of California and people would not identify themselves under one banner.
That's why i find it strange to claim that the fed does not equal America.