Posted: Wed Nov 16, 2005 4:14 am
Why would anybody bother with a sycophantic website? Count the posts, there are FAR more anti-canadian government postings than there are anti american comments. In fact in the last two days we saw several posts about how the US is far better on the environmental front than Canada. <br />
<br />
I come here for CANADIAN news. The only ongoing american remarks have been against american imperialism-of which the US itself is the world's largest provider (of anti american demonstrations I mean), far more than Canada. And softwood lumber, where the US is pretty blatantly defying international courts-why would ANYBODY suck up to that? Go to rural BC and go door to door and read them your letter, I know some now unemployed foresters who would just LOVE to have somebody close by with such a view, but not for any reasons healthy for you.<br />
<br />
As far as 'top universities and top supercomputers', that's just personal opinion and means squat. You might as well say we need the worlds largest super-silo's, or world's biggest pyramids. In fact, that worked great for Eygpt's and Las Vegas' tourism, let's build even BIGGER pyramids. For my money I'd rather see MORE universities with more canadians in them. Research is research, my wife works in cancer research and she has made more discoveries than ANY of the big labs that her company is associated with in the states, and THEY have all the big names with all the letters-and she doesn't even have a Phd. <br />
<br />
And of course we already know that the US doesn't provide any more medical research than europe, and most of it's wealth is used in marketing, maintaining patents, and enhancements on old medicine-and keeping medicines from people. Most of the biggest discoveries have all come from publicly funded universities, just like in Canada, but are now being sold off to industry-something that is also being fought far harder in the US than here in Canada. So again, it depends what is meant by 'america'. There is official federal policy, then there is what virtually every poll shows americans want-which is usually the complete opposite, much like Canada. Canadian research actually produces as many innovations as Canada consumes from other countries in medicine-go look it up. <br />
<br />
America is also not a race, there's virtually no court or recognized body that would maintain it was, and there are plenty of white and black fellas who would cut out your heart for saying that they are the same race. If your comments were true, then of course Brazilians are being 'segregationist' for not wanting to be part of Venezuela, and France is being 'segregationist' for not wanting to be part of Belgium.<br />
<br />
One remark was confusing, the 'under Bush' comment. 'Under Bush' is primarily descriptive as I would assume that 'no to deeper integration' would simply change to 'under insert President's name here', if the deeper integration issue is to continue-as I assume it will.<br />
<br />
As for american education it is structurally similar to Canada's. Canada has many well known academics-many of whom were run out of the US for 'unpopular research'. They simply aren't all at one school, like in the states where the ivy league schools can obviously pay for the best. In actual fact, in the science's a Master's degree in Canada is considered the equavalent of a Phd in most of the states. This is why so many canadians had the 'brain drain' opportunity. In Canada a Masters degree (in science, the area I know about) means almost nothing if you aren't continuing to a Phd or switching to another field (that's changing as research becomes more privatized). However, in the states a Masters from Canada is highly sought after-as I know from personal experience as well as from industry studies. With one tenth the population Canada easily has one tenth the academic standing of the US. Even with a small, lousy department here in __________, in __________, I can name three professors with international recognition attached to their name. As I said, they just aren't all at one school, therefore no one school stands out. If a country prefers, they can put all their eggs in one basket, that's their perogative-but only so many can get into Ivy league schools.<br />
<br />
So while it MAY be foolish to turn down a chance to go to Harvard, it certainly isn't foolish to turn down the chance to go to Pittsburgh's Inner City Trade School, or some such thing. I would probably agree that if you have the money and Harvard invites you, yes, you would be stupid to turn them down.<br />
<br />
<br />
So finally, as a person who is ACTIVELY trying to bring to Canada what I truly think is great about america, namely citizens initiatives, public participation in policy formulation, local ballot initiatives, local and state referenda, more elected and fewer nominated officials, an elected senate, and more potential for citizen involvement, and more citizen demands for participation-I think time is better spent simply FINDING the positives about the US and posting them in the forum or as news, which anybody is welcome to do. <br />
<br />
Obviously if you think what is great about the US is that they have supercomputers, ivy league schools, ignore international laws and stomp hell out of anybody they like, well, you'll find little accomodation here-and not nearly as much as you'd expect even in the states. <br />
<br />
<br />
<br />