CKA Forums
Login 
canadian forums
bottom
 
 
Canadian Forums

Author Topic Options
Offline
CKA Uber
CKA Uber
Profile
Posts: 10666
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 7:20 am
 


Xort Xort:
Wrote him a ticket. No need to arrest someone to write a ticket. He was no threat to anyone so it doesn't require him to be taken into custody.


So you have a guy that is a habitual offender with 30 prior arrests...a guy who continues to break the law and snub his nose at the police and local business and you walk by with a ticket and a "have a nice day"?

Garner was asked by police to leave the area where is was selling cigarettes. He refused. He demanded the cops leave him alone to his criminal activity.

Xort Xort:
If I had to arrest him, which isn't the case. I would explain that I was going to arrest him, ask for his cooperation, explain that if he doesn't comply that another more serious crime of resisting arrest would be added. If he refuses I would have had a number of officers close to support while I used a non lethal (non neck) take down, or join lock. I've personally been trained to do a wrist lock that will take down just about everyone using a single hand. Given that he wasn't fighting back their is no need for more aggressive action.


There's no need to explain. He's already been charged for resisting arrest. He knows what it's all about.

He wasn't fighting back? Did you watch the same video? The same guy who refused to co-operate and started whailing his arms around and refused to go to the ground?

Let's see you try your little wrist lock on a 6'4"- 400lb man.

Xort Xort:
Once on the ground and cuffed if he had complained about difficulty breathing that's a sign as anyone with even basic first aid knows of trouble. I'd monitor his condition, once he became unresponsive I'd start with first aid. So assess the situation, call for an ambulance and apply proper first aid.


Yea, people never complain they can't breathe after an intense physical interaction. I'm sure they've never heard that before. :roll:

Xort Xort:
What I wouldn't do is ignore him for 7 min, or use a lethal (neck area) banned rear naked choke hold on him just because he was a larger person. I also wouldn't jump right to physical force on a non violent person.


Of course it's easy for you to say. You're not there and you're also willing to overlook the guys criminal history, his size and the fact that he has a history of resisting arrest.


Offline
CKA Super Elite
CKA Super Elite
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 8851
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 9:21 am
 


xerxes xerxes:
True. But we're arguing semantics though. The NYPD has banned its use by its police officers, but it's not illegal per se.
Not really, because if it were illegal then without a doubt would have been a verdict of at least manslaughter. But because chokehold is only banned then no law was broken.


Offline
News Moderator
News Moderator
 Edmonton Oilers
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 19516

Warnings: (-20%)
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 9:45 am
 


Yogi Yogi:
xerxes xerxes:
True. But we're arguing semantics though. The NYPD has banned its use by its police officers, but it's not illegal per se.
Not really, because if it were illegal then without a doubt would have been a verdict of at least manslaughter. But because chokehold is only banned then no law was broken.

Would that be 2nd degree manslaughter then? Or involuntary manslaughter?


Offline
CKA Super Elite
CKA Super Elite
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 8851
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:01 am
 


Xort Xort:
OnTheIce OnTheIce:
But it's not against the law. You can't make up charges when no law exists.
Battery is a crime, police can use force on you but only approved force. The choke wasn't approved so the contact was not protected by his status as an officer. So it's battery.
$1:
What would you have done?
...
Do you taze him? What if his heart stops due to his health problems? Are we having this same conversation that they should have tried another way?
Wrote him a ticket. No need to arrest someone to write a ticket. He was no threat to anyone so it doesn't require him to be taken into custody.

If I had to arrest him, which isn't the case. I would explain that I was going to arrest him, ask for his cooperation, explain that if he doesn't comply that another more serious crime of resisting arrest would be added. If he refuses I would have had a number of officers close to support while I used a non lethal (non neck) take down, or join lock. I've personally been trained to do a wrist lock that will take down just about everyone using a single hand. Given that he wasn't fighting back their is no need for more aggressive action.

Once on the ground and cuffed if he had complained about difficulty breathing that's a sign as anyone with even basic first aid knows of trouble. I'd monitor his condition, once he became unresponsive I'd start with first aid. So assess the situation, call for an ambulance and apply proper first aid.

What I wouldn't do is ignore him for 7 min, or use a lethal (neck area) banned rear naked choke hold on him just because he was a larger person. I also wouldn't jump right to physical force on a non violent person.

Subject: Fw: Ferguson, MO opinion






This is a response someone posted to one of those Ferguson, MO posts...this is a good read and straight to the point....

My Name is William G. Lillas....

I wanted to clear up a few black and white questions and answers. The things I state are facts. They are not downloaded from some media website, not propaganda, just observations from a 83 year old black man, born in America:
"I was told by my parents (yes, a married man and woman with my last name), that I was nigger. We lived in “Nigger Town” in a small Texas town, no A/C, grass growing through the floor, no car, no TV. We washed our bodies with lye soap that my mother made, by hand. I thought I was a nigger, until I graduated high school, went to college, did an enlistment in the Army, and got a job. I am now retired, own my own home, have 6 children by ONE WOMAN, and we all have the same last name. I have a Bachelor’s Degree in Liberal Arts, a Master’s Degree in Sociology. My retirement, VA disability from combat in the Korean War (I only have one leg), and part-time pay in a local college, is about $125,000 a year. From dirt poor nigger, to old, black, proud American.
Yes, I am black, and I can say “nigger”, because I understand the true meaning of the word.
Let’s clear up a few things about the Michael Brown incident.
-Fact: It is not called "shoplifting or stealing", it's called "robbery", which is a felony. Brown stole something and assaulted someone, that means ROBBERY. It’s on video, and it’s a fact. Not shoplifting, not theft, not “lifting” a few cigars, but ROBBERY!
-Michael Brown, like Trayvon, was portrayed by the media as a “little black boy”, cute little headphones, and his cap and gown photo, gunned down by a ruthless police assassin, executed by “whitey”. First, I have never seen a cop drag a person into their car’s driver door to arrest them. So, let us be clear, Michael Brown was a nigger; a sorry assed, criminal, hoodlum, nigger. Nobody wants to say that, but I will. He had a criminal record a mile long, was known for numerous assaults, robberies, including the one you saw with your own eyes, and still refuse to call it a robbery. He was, like so many others, living a life that he thought he was “entitled” to, just for being alive. Gangsta rap, weed, drinking, guns, and those stupid-assed low profile rims, makes him some kind of bad-ass nigger.
-I have fought communist Chinese and North Korean soldiers in the 1950’s with more honor than that nigger. Yep, I peeled potatoes and shot communists. That’s the only job a nigger soldier could get.
Rodney King? Black Riots!
Trayvon? Black Riots!
-Hurricane Katrina? Black Riots! Stealing TV’s, designer clothes, etc.
-O.J. Simpson kills white man and white woman, found NOT GUILTY? Did white folks riot? Nope!
-In fact, when is the last time white people rioted? Civil War, maybe? That’s because they are, relatively, civilized people, much like many black Americans. Protesting is one thing, hell, I’m all for it. Even if you are an ignorant idiot, you have a right to protest.
-Stop only showing the young black "cap and gown" photos of Michael. Charles Manson may have a few of those laying around, as well. Show the nigger "gangsta" photos of the "poor unarmed teenager" (grown man) pics that have been removed from his Facebook page, holding the loaded pistol, smoking weed, with a mouthful of money.
-Militarization? The stupid-assed media that publicizes this has no idea what “militarization” really is. Cops wear helmets and vests, and drive armored vehicle because unemployed niggers thrown bricks at them, moron! You put on an "Adam 12" uniform and walk down the streets of Ferguson during the criminal riots. I can guarantee that you'll jump into the first armored "military tank" that you see.
-You only "want the police" when you "need the police", otherwise, you mock and fear what you do not understand about the police. And by the way, the police are trained to take your shit, but I wouldn’t fuck around with those Army National Guard, they aren’t as well disciplined “culturally” to take your shit like police do every day. They will ventilate your black asses with M-16s, with military precision and extreme prejudice.
-And finally, the way we protest and demand justice, is run down the streets breaking shit, looting stores, and acting like a bunch of untrained monkeys? Hell, after Rodney King, criminal niggers were actually killing people, thinking they were entitled to be worse criminals than they already were. For those black criminals that do that, you are a disgrace to your race, inflamed by idiots like Al Sharpton, instead of listening to logic from proud black Americans, like Bill Cosby, Samuel Jackson, Colin Powell, Allen West, me, etc.
-You blame white people for your ignorance, criminal acts, unemployed laziness, etc.
-You blame white people for 89% of the prisons in America being full of blacks. They did nothing wrong, the racists white cops framed them all, right? No chance at school, no chance for college, military, employment?
BULL SHIT!
-More niggers kill niggers, than niggers killing whites, whites killing niggers, and whites killing whites….COMBINED. I find this astounding.
-It's not white peoples' faults, the Emancipation Proclamation was signed by a white man years ago. You can go to school, get a job, buy a house, and vote, JUST LIKE WHITE FOLKS!!!! You are not a slave, you are not discriminated against! Slavery is abolished, and nobody alive today, was alive when it was popular. Get over it! You are discriminated against because you are a criminal, sorry-assed nigger. Otherwise, black Americans are treated like everyone else.
-If you choose to create "baby daddy and baby mama", and fake disabilities as an excuse for laziness to draw social security disability…… instead of husband, wife, family, job, mortgage, it's YOUR FAULT, not white folks. And there are a lot of proud black Americans that will tell you the same, as I AM ONE OF THEM!!!
-Remember, the way you act on the camera, is remembered by everyone who sees it. They will never forget it. It shows them how you, as the black race, respond to situations that don’t particularly go the way you think they should. It will become a reference standard, something they expect from you when the next media report doesn’t go your way. Stop being stupid niggers, and be a proud black American. My parents raised me well, but they were wrong about one thing, I am not a nigger.
I will not be around long. While my mind is still sharp, and my aim is still good, my body is eating away with cancer. It started in the prostate, and is spreading rapidly. After I die, I have asked my children to publish my writings, and include my name. Although I am not expecting any miracles, I can only hope that Americans will stop blaming color, start blaming criminals, and see people for what the y really are. We have too many countries that want us dead. We should not be fighting each other.

"William G. Lillas"


Offline
CKA Moderator
CKA Moderator
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 53332
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:11 am
 


^^ That, is friggen awesome!


Offline
CKA Uber
CKA Uber
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 33492
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:27 am
 


Yeah sure. I wonder how he got his sociology degree thinking that black and white. And his rant solves nothing. Just calling people niggers and saying they should pull themselves up by their bootstraps isn't going to do it, just perpetuates the situation with people not in it feeling sanctimonious.

On the other hand, like bill cosby, this also has to be said, can't only make excuses. Two way street. The righties will seize on this to do nothing, the lefties will condemn it as victim blaming.

I do agree with him about Michael Brown tho. And the media, and how it loves to heat people up, then gets to stand back and film the riots. Ratings people!


Offline
CKA Uber
CKA Uber


GROUP_AVATAR
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 42160
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:27 am
 


Snopes says.............bogus

http://www.snopes.com/politics/soapbox/blackvet.asp


Offline
CKA Super Elite
CKA Super Elite
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 8851
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:46 am
 


ShepherdsDog ShepherdsDog:



'Snopes'website is getting a lot of attention right now and keeps freezing up. I don't know why 'snopes' is considered to be 'the authority', but be that as it may' regardless of where/how the article originated it is an excellent piece.


Offline
Forum Super Elite
Forum Super Elite
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 2366
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:58 am
 


OnTheIce OnTheIce:
So you have a guy that is a habitual offender with 30 prior arrests...a guy who continues to break the law and snub his nose at the police and local business and you walk by with a ticket and a "have a nice day"?
Yes because that's the law. Issue a ticket.
$1:
Garner was asked by police to leave the area where is was selling cigarettes. He refused. He demanded the cops leave him alone to his criminal activity.
He broke up a fight and waited around for the police to come, who then targeted him for some harassment given his past activities.

$1:
There's no need to explain. He's already been charged for resisting arrest. He knows what it's all about.
Their is always a need to explain, and when their is time always a need to be polite.
$1:
He wasn't fighting back? Did you watch the same video? The same guy who refused to co-operate and started whailing his arms around and refused to go to the ground?
Fighting back would be offensive hostile actions like throwing punches, trying to grab someone. He took no hostile action. Pulling your arm away from someone isn't an attack. Having someone try and kill you with a banned lethal choke and pull you to the ground by your neck would rate the low level non hostile reaction he gave.
$1:
Let's see you try your little wrist lock on a 6'4"- 400lb man.
It causes intense pain and everyone tries to follow the movement of the wrist to prevent the pain. You can take someone to the ground and cause them to roll about with the lock control. Size doesn't matter so one as you have enough upper body strength to push a wrist down, which everyone does.

Also that guy while a bigger than me isn't wildly out of my class. I'm not a manlet cop like the guy that used the banned choke on him.

$1:
Yea, people never complain they can't breathe after an intense physical interaction. I'm sure they've never heard that before. :roll:
Doesn't matter. You are not a doctor, (I don't think) if they are is distress you must give aid no matter how many times some crackhead has claimed a medical complication.

What you just said is that you ignore people in distress because of what other people did.

$1:
Of course it's easy for you to say. You're not there and you're also willing to overlook the guys criminal history, his size and the fact that he has a history of resisting arrest.


His criminal history means nothing, as he was a free man at the time. You can tell the difference because free men are not in jail.

As for his size, so what? Him being big doesn't mean I get to skip past being polite and asking for cooperation.

As for resisting arrest, any action other than complete obedience is resisting arrest. A person standing not moving and not resisting is resisting arrest. That bar is too low and is effectively useless.

Not that it matters you have clearly stated that you shouldn't give aid to someone because other people complained about their health while being arrested.


Offline
CKA Uber
CKA Uber
Profile
Posts: 10666
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 11:18 am
 


Xort Xort:
Yes because that's the law. Issue a ticket.


Want to follow the law? Sure. He was under probation. Selling loosies was a breach of that probation.

Do we issue tickets for breach of probation now?

Xort Xort:
He broke up a fight and waited around for the police to come, who then targeted him for some harassment given his past activities.


Right. Just an upstanding citizen waiting for the cops. :roll:
Xort Xort:
Their is always a need to explain, and when their is time always a need to be polite.


Looks like they were quite polite until Mr. Garner opted not to comply.

Xort Xort:
Doesn't matter. You are not a doctor, (I don't think) if they are is distress you must give aid no matter how many times some crackhead has claimed a medical complication.


Maybe they thought he wasn't in distress and that it was another excuse by a fat guy that just wrestled with the police.

Having your heart stop from a simple takedown isn't normal, even a chokehold..they could not have expected the outcome of this interaction nor the underlying health problems.

Xort Xort:

His criminal history means nothing, as he was a free man at the time. You can tell the difference because free men are not in jail.


He was on probation. He was not a "free" man, according to the law.

Xort Xort:
As for his size, so what? Him being big doesn't mean I get to skip past being polite and asking for cooperation.

As for resisting arrest, any action other than complete obedience is resisting arrest. A person standing not moving and not resisting is resisting arrest. That bar is too low and is effectively useless.


They were polite, up until he refused to comply. When you act like that, the level of politeness ends quickly.

Xort Xort:
Not that it matters you have clearly stated that you shouldn't give aid to someone because other people complained about their health while being arrested.


Not at all....but all the bullshit cops hear from those in custody. "The cuffs are too tight", "I can't breathe", you can't blame them for being skeptical when they hear the same old song and dance.


Offline
Forum Super Elite
Forum Super Elite
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 2366
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 12:09 pm
 


OnTheIce OnTheIce:
Want to follow the law? Sure. He was under probation. Selling loosies was a breach of that probation.
Do we issue tickets for breach of probation now?

Was that officer acting under a court order to arrest him for his breach of probation?
Had his guilt in selling those smokes been proven at that time? What their some passing street judge that gave him a guilty sentence?
Issue him a ticket when it hits the system if that was a violation of his probation then the probation system kicks in and deals with him.

Are you claiming they arrested him because of a probation violation? Because that's not what the police said happened.
$1:
Right. Just an upstanding citizen waiting for the cops.
Yeah or are you claiming the fight he broke up didn't happen?
$1:
Looks like they were quite polite until Mr. Garner opted not to comply.
No they started with harassment and never stopped.
$1:
Maybe they thought he wasn't in distress and that it was another excuse by a fat guy that just wrestled with the police.
Doesn't matter.
$1:
Having your heart stop from a simple takedown isn't normal, even a chokehold..they could not have expected the outcome of this interaction nor the underlying health problems.
Which is why they ignored him, because his communication of his distress was just him being fat.

Also they kept on ignoring him for 7min after became unresponsive and slumped over.
$1:
He was on probation. He was not a "free" man, according to the law.
He was a free man as he wasn't in jail. The officers were not his probation officer and were not acting on a court order to take him back into custody.
$1:
They were polite, up until he refused to comply. When you act like that, the level of politeness ends quickly.
They were never polite the plain clothes officer started out being hostile and never stopped.
$1:
Not at all....but all the bullshit cops hear from those in custody. "The cuffs are too tight", "I can't breathe", you can't blame them for being skeptical when they hear the same old song and dance.

I can blame them for it. They should be in jail for manslaughter because they should have taken his requests for aid seriously and acted with due diligence to protect someone in there custody.


Offline
CKA Uber
CKA Uber
Profile
Posts: 10666
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 12:39 pm
 


Well, it's clear that both the police and the grand jury disagree with you wholeheartedly.

You and I will agree to disagree as well.


Offline
CKA Elite
CKA Elite
 Los Angeles Kings
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 4661
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 2:11 pm
 


The police and the grand jury are from New York City, which is just slightly better than Chicago.


Offline
CKA Moderator
CKA Moderator
 Vancouver Canucks


GROUP_AVATAR
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 65472
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 3:14 pm
 


andyt andyt:
Yeah sure. I wonder how he got his sociology degree thinking that black and white.


Yeah, how did he do better in life than a Marxist whose only hope in life is to somehow force other people to provide for him? [huh]


Offline
CKA Moderator
CKA Moderator
 Vancouver Canucks


GROUP_AVATAR
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 65472
PostPosted: Thu Dec 04, 2014 3:59 pm
 


The winner of the internet today is...


Attachments:
File comment: c
Capture.PNG
Capture.PNG [ 203.63 KiB | Viewed 139 times ]
Post new topic  Reply to topic  [ 53 posts ]  Previous  1  2  3  4  Next



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 40 guests




 
     
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner.
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © Canadaka.net. Powered by © phpBB.