Mount Logan
(I'm tall (6'3"), but not
that tall!)
Your clue, sir or madam:
Neither of the guys with a Keith's had a Moosehead.
The last clue:
Ef fen qru cjf gvctqnab fo cqn brzn snna reu ef cjf pdlb qru cqn brzn cjf xveub fo snna.
To unscramble this, unless you're really good, you'll have to go to the website listed in my profile (you might not have much luck in my CKA profile, though

)
Those are all the clues, so you should then be able to figure out who drank what. Each person drank two, remember, and PM your answers to me with the subject "Blue_Nose is awesome" to find out if you win.